top of page
  • jcohen664

Dog Ownership Lawyer: Navigating Pet Custody in Divorce & Disputes

Updated: Sep 14


When it comes to the dissolution of a relationship or disputes over pet ownership, the fate of beloved dogs can be a contentious issue. Many people consider their dogs as family members, leading to emotional battles over custody. Pet custody disputes can arise in various relationships, including former spouses, romantic partners, roommates, and friends. Even intra-family cases, involving relatives like mothers and daughters, brothers, aunts, and nieces, can lead to disagreements over the ownership and custody of beloved dogs or cats. At Boston Dog Lawyers, we specialize in resolving these emotionally charged cases and strive to find fair and amicable solutions. In this article, we will delve into the intricacies of pet custody disputes and highlight the importance of professional guidance in navigating these challenging situations.

Understanding Pet Custody in Divorce and Separation

Divorce and separation often bring up the question, "Who gets the dog?" Although pets are cherished companions, they are considered property under the law in Massachusetts. This means that the court system typically treats them as assets to be divided, similar to other possessions like furniture or vehicles. However, the emotional attachment people have with their dogs has prompted a shift in the way some courts approach pet custody.

Factors Influencing Dog Custody Decisions

  • Best Interests of the Dog: Just as in child custody cases, courts are beginning to consider the best interests of the dog. This includes evaluating the dog's well-being, emotional connection with each owner, and living environment. Massachusetts judges are not authorized to include this factor in their decision-making.

  • Pet Custody Agreements: In some cases, divorcing parties can draft pet custody agreements to determine visitation schedules and responsibilities. While these agreements are generally not enforceable in family court, they can serve as a guide for both parties to ensure a smooth transition and ongoing care for the dog.

  • Possession and Bill of Sale: The possession of the pet often plays a significant role in determining custody. If the parties cannot agree, the bill of sale or registration documents may indicate ownership and influence custody decisions.

  • Living Arrangements: Courts consider the living situations of both parties when determining dog custody. Factors such as suitable housing, available space, and the presence of children are taken into account.

  • Safety Concerns: If there are concerns about the safety of the dog, such as violence or abuse, some states allow for pet restraining orders to protect the pet's well-being.

Resolving Dog Ownership Disputes


Mediation is often an effective approach to resolving dog ownership disputes. It allows both parties to discuss their concerns, emotions, and desires for the dog's future in a controlled and neutral setting. A mediator can help facilitate communication and guide the parties toward a mutually beneficial agreement.

Preventing Disputes

To avoid conflicts over pet custody, it is advisable to address the issue proactively. Couples should consider creating a pet custody agreement, similar to a prenuptial agreement, that outlines the responsibilities and expectations for each party in the event of separation or divorce.

Prioritizing Resolution through Cooperation

When faced with pet custody disputes, our first priority is to encourage the parties involved to resolve the issue amicably and independently. Collaborative decision-making is often preferable, allowing the parties to retain control over the outcome. We provide assistance by facilitating discussions and helping draft visitation agreements or joint custody contracts that clearly outline each party's rights and responsibilities. However, we understand that circumstances can change, misunderstandings can arise, and one party may fail to honor the agreed-upon arrangements. In such cases, legal intervention becomes necessary.


If mediation fails or the dispute escalates, litigation becomes necessary. Experienced dog ownership lawyers can represent clients in court, presenting arguments based on ownership history, living arrangements, and the best interests of the dog.

Advocating for Pet Owners in Court

When court involvement becomes necessary, our clients benefit from our extensive experience in handling pet custody cases. Each case is unique, and we focus on understanding the crucial factor of "when" a once jointly-owned pet became the sole property of one party. Courts often struggle to identify the pivotal legal and factual issues involved, which is where our expertise guides their understanding.

While pets are considered personal property under the law, we advocate for considering what is in the best interests of the dog or cat involved. Various factors come into play, such as ownership, registration, veterinary care, training, companionship history, living situations of the parties, work schedules, resources, and experience. With numerous indicators of ownership, there are numerous ways to argue pet custody cases. Our goal is to break through any resistance, whether it comes from the court, opposing lawyers, the parties themselves, or family members. We tirelessly advocate for our client's rights and leverage our prior experience to build stronger legal arguments.

The Emotional Toll of Dog Custody Battles

Dog custody battles can be emotionally draining for all parties involved. The attachment and love people have for their dogs often make these disputes particularly challenging. It is crucial to prioritize the well-being of the dog throughout the process and avoid seeking victory at the expense of the dog's happiness.

The Emotional Value of Successful Pet Recovery

One of the most rewarding aspects of our work is reuniting clients with their beloved pets when they were initially told they would never see them again. These cases often require significant effort and unwavering advocacy, but we are committed to meeting our client's urgent needs concerning their cherished companions. At Boston Dog Lawyers, we understand the deep emotional bond between humans and their pets, and we take pride in fighting for our client's rights in these emotionally charged situations.


Pet custody disputes can escalate quickly and become emotionally taxing for all parties involved. Seeking professional guidance from a dog ownership lawyer is essential to navigating these complex cases successfully. By prioritizing cooperation, advocating for the best interests of the pet, and leveraging our experience in court, we work diligently to find equitable resolutions. Our ultimate goal is to protect the well-being of the animals involved while ensuring that our client's rights are upheld.

The information provided in this article is for educational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice.

bottom of page