top of page
  • jcohen664

My Ex Took My Dog: Legal Options & Steps to Take

Updated: Sep 14, 2023

Losing custody of a beloved pet can be heartbreaking, especially when it happens after a breakup or divorce. If you find yourself in a situation where your ex has taken your dog and won't return them, it's essential to know your legal rights and available options. In this article, we will explore the steps you can take to regain custody of your furry friend. From understanding the legal framework to pursuing a small claims lawsuit, we'll provide you with valuable insights and guidance.

Understanding the Legalities

Laws Regarding Dog Ownership

In most jurisdictions, including Boston, pets are considered legal property. Therefore, when your ex takes your dog without your consent, it is regarded as unauthorized possession of your property.

Civil Court Action

To resolve the situation legally, you can file a lawsuit in civil court against your ex in the county where they reside. Depending on your ex's location, you will sue in the corresponding county. For example, if your ex lives in Boston, you would file the lawsuit in Suffolk County.


In the court case, you will likely invoke property laws, specifically replevin or partition, depending on the circumstances. These legal actions will help you establish evidence of your ownership and seek a judgment in your favor.

Seeking Assistance from Animal Lawyers

Expertise in Dealing with Pet Custody Cases

At Boston Dog Lawyers, our experienced animal lawyers specialize in cases like yours. We understand the complexities of disputes involving pets and can guide you through the legal process to help you reclaim your dog.

Steps to Take When Your Ex Takes Your Dog

Resolving pet custody issues without court intervention is often preferred. However, if communication fails and legal intervention becomes necessary, there are steps you can take to protect your rights and increase your chances of regaining custody:

Attempt Communication and Mediation

  • Open Communication: Initiating an open and honest conversation with your ex can sometimes lead to a resolution. Share your feelings and explain the impact of losing your beloved pet. Help them understand the importance of reuniting you with your dog.

  • Mediation Services: Consider suggesting mediation as an alternative dispute resolution method. Many organizations offer free or low-cost mediation services, and some courts provide mediation opportunities. This approach can help both parties reach a mutually acceptable solution without the need for a lawsuit.

  • Seeking Amicable Resolutions: Attempt to negotiate and draft visitation agreements or joint custody contracts that outline the rights and responsibilities of all parties involved. If circumstances change, misunderstandings develop, or the sharing agreement is not honored, legal intervention becomes necessary.

Gathering Evidence

Importance of Documentation

To strengthen your case, it is crucial to collect and preserve evidence that supports your claim of ownership. The following evidence can be instrumental in establishing your rightful ownership:

  • Vet Records: Gather documents showing your name as the registered owner of the dog and any receipts of medical expenses you have paid.

  • Financial Transactions: Provide evidence of financial contributions, such as receipts for food, medications, or toys you purchased for your dog.

  • Agreements or Contracts: If any agreements were made with your ex regarding shared custody or return of the dog, gather any written or digital documentation.

  • Witness Statements: Statements from friends, family, or neighbors who can attest to your role as the primary caregiver and owner of the dog.

  • Police Reports: If you suspect your dog was stolen, file a police report and keep a copy to present as evidence.

  • Microchip Records: If your dog is microchipped, obtain the microchip record showing your ownership details.

Sending a Demand Letter

The Purpose of a Demand Letter

Consider sending a demand letter to your ex before pursuing legal action. This demand letter serves as a formal request for the return of your dog and can often resolve the issue without going to court. It demonstrates your seriousness and willingness to take legal action if necessary.

Contents of a Demand Letter

When writing a demand letter, include the following information:

  • Clear Statement: Begin the letter with a clear and concise statement that you are the dog's rightful owner and that your ex has wrongfully taken possession of the animal.

  • Ownership Evidence: Briefly mention the evidence you have gathered to support your ownership claim, such as vet records, receipts, agreements, or witness statements.

  • Request for Return: Clearly state your demand for the immediate return of your dog to your possession. Provide a specific deadline by which you expect a response.

  • Consequences: Inform your ex of the potential legal consequences they may face if they fail to comply with your demand, such as legal action, financial liability, or potential criminal charges.

  • Contact Information: Include your contact information so that your ex can respond or communicate with you regarding the matter.

  • Professional Tone: Keep the tone of the letter professional and avoid any emotional language or personal attacks. Stick to the facts and maintain a respectful demeanor.

Filing a Lawsuit in Small Claims Court

Small Claims Court Jurisdiction

If communication, mediation, and the demand letter fail to resolve the situation, you may consider filing a lawsuit in small claims court. Small claims court is a legal venue designed for resolving disputes involving relatively small amounts of money, and in some cases, the return of personal property.

Pet Custody in the Courtroom

In court proceedings, focus on determining the crucial aspect of "when" the once jointly-owned pet became solely owned by one party. Consider factors such as ownership, registration, veterinary care, training, companionship history, living situations, work schedules, resources, and experience of the parties involved. Advocate for your rights and construct strong arguments based on prior experiences to break through barriers of resistance from the court, opposing lawyers, or the parties involved.

Steps to File a Lawsuit in Small Claims Court

  • Research Local Laws: Familiarize yourself with the specific small claims court procedures and jurisdiction in your area. Each jurisdiction may have slightly different rules and limits for filing a lawsuit.

  • Complete Necessary Forms: Obtain the required forms for initiating a small claims lawsuit. These forms can usually be obtained online or from the small claims court clerk's office.

  • Fill Out the Forms: Provide accurate information on the forms, including your name, address, your ex's name and address, and a detailed description of the case. Attach any relevant evidence that supports your ownership claim.

  • File the Forms: Submit the completed forms to the small claims court clerk along with the appropriate filing fee. The clerk will provide you with a court date and copies of the forms.

  • Serve the Papers: Ensure that your ex is properly served with the court documents. This can be done by hiring a professional process server or using certified mail with a return receipt.

  • Prepare for the Court Hearing: Organize all the evidence you have collected and prepare your arguments for the court hearing. Be prepared to present your case to the judge and provide evidence of your ownership.

  • Attend the Court Hearing: On the scheduled court date, appear in court and present your case. Be respectful, concise, and stick to the relevant facts. Answer any questions the judge may have.

  • Await the Judge's Decision: The judge will review the evidence and make a decision based on the facts presented. If the judge rules in your favor, they may order your ex to return the dog to you or provide compensation for the wrongful possession.

The Reward of Reuniting with Your Pet

Successfully reuniting with your beloved pet is a gratifying moment. Boston Dog Lawyers is committed to meeting clients' most urgent needs concerning their cherished pets, putting in significant effort and unwavering advocacy.


Losing custody of your dog to an ex can be distressing, but there are legal options available to help you regain possession. Understanding the legal framework, seeking assistance from animal lawyers, attempting communication and mediation, gathering evidence, sending a demand letter, and, if necessary, filing a lawsuit in small claims court are steps you can take to protect your rights as a pet owner.

In Boston, Massachusetts, resolving pet custody disputes can be a complex and emotional process. However, with the assistance of experienced legal professionals and a commitment to pursuing amicable solutions, it is possible to regain ownership of your beloved pet. Seeking timely resolution through negotiation, mediation, or legal action, if necessary, can help ensure the best interests of the pet are considered. Boston Dog Lawyers is dedicated to guiding clients through the legal process and advocating tirelessly to protect their rights as pet owners.

The information provided in this article is for educational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice.

134 views0 comments


bottom of page